If you have a news tip send us an email at: tips@oregoncapitalinsider.com

Universal health care measure dies in Senate

A voter referral to amend the Oregon Constitution to make health care a fundamental right lacked enough votes to pass the Senate, according to Senate leaders.

JAIME VALDEZ/PORTLAND TRIBUNE - The 2018 Oregon Legislative Assembly in the House of Representatives at the Oregon State CapitolSALEM — A legislative referral to ask voters to amend the Constitution to make access to cost-effective and affordable health care the right of all Oregon residents lacks the votes to pass the Senate, according to Senate Democrats.

Despite proposed wording changes, "there were still concerns about individual suing the state," said Sen. Laurie Monnes Anderson, D-Gresham, chairwoman of the Senate Health Committee.

"We were just down to the wire. Trying to come to an agreement on language changes was just really tough."

The measure, called House Joint Referral 203, passed the House along party lines Feb. 13.

Monnes Anderson announced Monday, Feb. 26, that her committee would not hold a vote on the referral. Even though the committee had enough votes to send the measure to the Senate floor, there are not enough votes to pass the bill in the larger body, she said.

"The bill would have needed extensive amendments for it to get the support it needs in the Senate, and given this late timing in the session, the committee chair made the difficult decision to not move forward with it," said Senate Majority Leader Ginny Burdick, D-Portland.

Had the referral been approved in the Legislature, the proposal would have gone to voters in the November general election.

In the House, all 35 Democrats voted for the measure, while the 25 Republicans opposed it.

JAIME VALDEZ/PORTLAND TRIBUNE - Rep. Mitch Greenlick, D-Portland, chairman of the House Health Care CommitteeThis is the third consecutive time the Senate has blocked the referral, said Rep. Mitch Greenlick, D-Portland, who has repeatedly sponsored the measure.

In light of federal efforts to overturn the Affordable Care Act, Greenlick said it is important for Oregon voters to weigh in on whether they want health care to be accessible to everyone.

"I think we are making a terrible mistake not to give them the opportunity to tell us whether they really believe that universal access to health care is something that our citizens deserve and that we should take seriously as we consider how we move forward in dealing with the health care system," he said.

Using a catchphrase from the 1984 science fiction film, "The Terminator," Greenlick said: "I will be back."

The practical impact of creating such a right was unclear.

House Speaker Tina Kotek and Majority Leader Jennifer Williamson, both Democrats from Portland, described the measure primarily as "aspirational," but some legal experts said adding the right to the Constitution could spur litigation.

"I think we all agree that health care should be an inalienable right for everyone. I'm concerned that you send it to the voters and the voters say yes and it comes back, at what expense do we pay for it?" said Sen. Alan DeBoer, R-Ashland, a member of the Senate Health Care Committee. "We need the federal government to come to the table. I have always been a supporter of single payer … but how do you pay for it once you approve it and the lawsuits?"

Paris Achen
Portland Tribune Capital Bureau
email: pachen@portlandtribune.com
Follow us on Twitter
Visit Us on Facebook

Access your account

Subscriber Login

cialiscialis couponcialis genericcialis dosagegeneric cialiscialis costcialis vs viagracialis pricescialis side effectscialis couponscialis 30 day sampleviagra vs cialiscialis onlinecialis pillscialis samplesbuy cialiscialis 20 mgcialis patent expirationcialis coupons printablecialis for daily usecialis samples overnightcheap cialiscost of cialis200 cialis couponcialis dailycialis 20mggeneric cialis at walmartcealiscialis canadacialis trialhow does cialis workwhen will cialis go genericcialis on lineside effects of cialiscialis 30 day trial couponcialis 5mgcialis for mencialasbuy cialis onlinecialis for salecialis patent expiration date extendedhow to take cialiscialis pricecialis from canadahow much does cialis costfree cialisviagra vs cialis vs levitracialis reviewscialis coupons from manufacturerwhat is cialiscialis pills for salecialis patent expiration 2017canadian cialiscialis tadalafilcialis or viagrageneric for cialiscialis professionalcialis free trialcialis medicationciliascialis for bphcialis coupons 2017cyaliscialis dosage strengthscialis discountgeneric cialis tadalafildiscount cialiscialis dosage recommendationscialis 5 mgonline cialiscialis canadian pharmacycialis copay cardlowest cialis pricescialis for womencialis generic availabilitycialis vouchercialis savings cardcialis 10 mgcialis websitecialis generic tadalafilliquid cialisdaily cialisviagra cialiscialis otcerectile dysfunction cialiscialis 5mg dailycanada cialiscialis coupon 20 mgcialis pricingcialis coupon printviamedic cialiscialis cheapcialis pharmacy pricescialis 20mg directionsprice cialiscialis samplewholesale cialiscialis alternativecialis effectscialis testimonialslevitralevitra couponlevitra 20 mglevitra 20mgbuy levitralevitra priceslevitra genericlevitra onlinelevitra vs viagrageneric levitralevitra couponslevitra rezeptfrei deutschlandlevitra 10 mg prezzocheap levitra9 levitra at walmartlevitra erfahrungenlevitra dosageviagra vs cialis vs levitrageneric levitra vardenafil 20mgwhat works better than viagrabuy levitra onlinelevitra without a doctor prescriptionbuy generic levitralevitra 20mg cost per pillvardenafil 20mglevitra prezzo in farmacialevitra 20 mg precio farmaciavardenafil vs viagralevitra 20 mg cost walmartlevitra vs viagra for hardnesslevitra bayer 20mg meilleur prixlevitra 20 mg von bayerviagrageneric viagraviagra genericviagra couponsviagra without a doctor prescriptionviagra onlineequipe argentine viagraviagra pricesbuy viagracialis vs viagracheap viagraviagra pillsviagra samplesviagra side effectswhat is viagraviagra couponviagra naturalviagra dosageviagra for sale uknatural viagrabuy viagra onlinegeneric viagra 100mgfemale viagrahow does viagra workhow to use viagraviagra activateherbal viagraviagra tabletssophia viagraviagra sans ordonnanceviagra kaufenviagra tabletviagra vs cialisonline viagracanadian viagraviagra for womenviagra ohne rezept aus deutschlandpfizer viagraviagra 100mgviagra costfree viagraviagra alternativesviagra canadaviagra on lineviagra single packsviagra for menviagra pillviagra 100mg tablets retail priceorder viagraviagra tescoside effects of viagraviagra pillen kruidvatviagra for salediscount viagrawhat does viagra doviagra costsviagra uklevitra vs viagrawhere to buy viagraviagra substitutehow long does viagra lastviagra alternativeviagra receptfrittviagra priceviagra 100viagra en ligne livraison 24hviagra on line no precviagra 100 mgutilisation viagrabest price viagracost of viagraviagra sexviagra wikipediasex viagra for womenviagra nebenwirkungenrevatio vs viagraviagra without a doctor prescription usaviagra genericoviagra 50mgviagra from canadaover the counter viagraviagra effectsviagra medicinepfizer viagra coupons from pfizerbuy generic viagraviagra wikiviagra bestellenviagra ohne rezept auf rechnungcanada viagrawomen viagrabuying viagraviagra soft